19 Easy Cookie Cutter Recipes (2024)

Here is the best cookie-cutter recipe collection. Make beautiful and adorable cookies with these specifically created cut out cookie recipes. Enjoy perfectly shaped and cute masterpieces, excellent for Christmas or another special occasion.

Have you searched for a perfect cut outcookie recipe during the holiday season?

Have you ever wondered why one type of cookie dough works for your favorite cookie cutter, and others don't?

And what are the best recipes for cookie cutters?

This guide will answer all your questions. So get ready to purchase the fun cookie cutters because the recipes below will make perfect cookies for any occasion.

What are cut out cookies

Cut-out cookies, also known as rolled cookies, are cookies cut into different shapes out of the rolled dough.

The easiest way to cut the cookies is to use specially-designed cookie cutters. So these types of cookies are also called cookie cutter cookies.

Cut-out cookies differ from drop cookies made from dough balls scooped onto a baking sheet.

Let's look at the difference between cut-out cookies and drop cookies.

Cut out cookie recipes

If you want to make perfectly-shaped cookies with intricate designs, here is a list of cookie cutter cookie recipes to help you get started.

Cookies created with these recipes are the best cut out cookies that hold their shape!

1. Cut out sugar cookies

Cut-out sugar cookies are classic cookies. They are the best at holding shapes and have flat surfaces perfect for decoration. These classic treats can be found all over the Internet and on social media.

The chilling and no-chill cutout sugar cookies are actually two different types. One type requires chilling the dough before cutting, shaping, and baking, while another doesn't require any chilling at all.

With all the decoration options, let your creativity go wild. Use royal icing, sugar cookie frosting, lemon or chocolate glaze, or buttercream. Finally, generously sprinkle cookies with assorted sprinkles.

2. Brown sugar cut out cookies

These brown sugar cut out cookies are a beautiful twist on classic sugar cookies. Adding brown sugar brings a softer texture, a light molasses flavor, and the perfect cookie cutter shape.

What's more? They don't require chilling! Leave your cookies plain, or decorate them in the way you desire.

3. Chocolate cut out cookies

Also known as chocolatesugar cookies, they are a delicious alternative to traditional sugar cookies.

Soft in the middle with crisp edges and flavored with chocolate, these treats are perfect for including in your holiday cookie box.

Leave them undecorated, or use royal icing to look even more elegant.

4. Almond flour cut out cookies

These Christmas cookie ornaments are almond flour cookies, perfect for cutouts. The dough is versatile and forgiving, making it great to work with the fanciest cookie cuter.

The cookies are soft and crumbly, with a delicious nutty flavor. They perfectly retain the shape to make a Christmas tree decoration.

5. Red velvet cut out cookies

These are another type of the perfect cutouts, colorful and festive, wonderfully soft, and full of the signature red velvet flavor.

These red velvet cut out cookies, perfect for Valentine's Day, will surely make your day.

6. Cinnamon cut out cookies

These cinnamon star cutouts are the perfect German Christmas cookies. The dough is easy to make and will give you intricate shapes like five or six-pointed stars, depending on how big your cutter is.

Enjoy these cookies during the holiday; they are full of irresistible cinnamon flavor that will keep people coming back for more.

7. Shortbread cut out cookies

Some of the most delicious cut-out cookies are shortbread. You can make your favorite buttery, melt-in-your-mouth treats with just a few simple ingredients.

This easy-to-prepare dough comes together quickly: just opt for the simplest cuter design.

Then, leave your cookies undecorated or give them some extra flair with your own personal touch.

8. Peanut butter cut out cookies

Peanut butter cut-out cookies are a delicious and easy way to make your favorite childhood memories come alive.

The cookies are soft and hold their shape perfectly when baked. You can decorate them with your favorite frosting recipe, royal icing, or a simple chocolate ganache to make them even prettier.

9. Butter cut out cookies

You are lucky enough that you have found the best butter cookie recipe.

These cut out butter cookies are a delicious way to use cookie cutters. They hold their shape very well for most simple shapes and turn out perfectly every time.

The best part is that you can even leave them uniced if you prefer.

The texture stays soft, which gives this recipe its signature ultra-creamy and milky sweet delicate flavor.

10. Condensed milk cut out cookies

The old-fashioned sweetened condensed milk cut-out cookies are one of the best sugar cookies with exceptional shape precision. They are baked to perfection without spreading during baking.

You will love these delicious and impressive cookies, perfect for any occasion.

11. Cream cheese cut out cookies

Adding cream cheese to cookie dough brings tenderness and a subtle tang to finished cookies. And thanks to this secret ingredient, the dough is easy to work with.

As a result, these cream cheese cut-out cookies are perfect in shape with a soft, cake-like texture.

12. Pumpkin spice cut out cookies

Soft pumpkin spice cut out sugar cookies are perfect for decorating with icing and sprinkles.

Their perfect shape, crisp edges, soft centers, and incredible flavor make them the ultimate cookie cutter cookies to serve at a Halloween party or other special occasion.

13. Gingerbread cut out cookies

There are few things more festive than gingerbread cutouts during the holiday season.

The recipe for these tasty treats has been around for centuries, making them an old favorite among families worldwide.

14. Molasses cut out cookies

These delicious molasses cut out cookies are the perfect way to celebrate Christmas.

They closely resemble the flavor of gingerbread cookies. Plus, you can't beat their incredible taste when everyone needs something sweet and unique during this time of year.

15. Anise cut out cookies

Please look no further than these anise citrus cutout cookies if you want to make some delicious holiday cookies for your friends and family during the Christmas holidays.

The recipe is really easy to follow, and it will give you perfect cutouts every time.

The cookies are crispy on the edges, delicately flavored, and beautiful to look at. They will surely be a big hit at your next party.

16. Coffee cut out cookies

You should definitely try coffee sugar cutout cookies this holiday season. They are chewy and soft and infused with coffee and espresso flavors.

Enjoy them plain, with silky vanilla bean buttercream, or dipped in chocolate. All options are absolutely delicious!

17. Apple spiced cutout cookies

These are one of the best spiced cutout cookies made with spiced apple powder drink mix, Lorann pumpkin spice, ground cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and even pumpkin puree.

18. Rainbow funfetti cutout cookies

Enjoy your baking with these playful funfetty cut out sugar cookies. They are perfect for any occasion, whether it is a festive Christmas celebration or a lovely birthday party.

Add rainbow jimmies (or nonpariels rainbow sprinkles) to your cookie dough, and let the colorful fun begin.

19. Snickerdoodle cut out cookies

Let's honestly confirm that making perfectly shaped Snickerdoodle cut-out cookies is challenging.

The traditional cream-of tartar dough tends to spread during baking, making slightly misshapen cookies.

But still, you can make good enough-looking cutouts with the iconic tangy flavor. So, this is the least recommended recipe for making cut-out cookies.

Conclusion

This recipe collection is the perfect way to get your holiday spirit going. Whether you are thinking about Halloween or Christmas, there are so many different cookie dough recipes that will fit any flavor.

You can make plain cutout cookies for those who want something simple. Or decorate your cookies for those who appreciate all of this embellishment.

Happy baking!